The Rivalry, Esq.: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Around SBN: Want to help build SB Nation? We're hiring! Bar-right-arrows



spread the word

It was the best of times, it was the worst of times...

Yeah, I know.  I'm a walking allusional cliche. 

But when it comes down to it, what better way is there to preface a regular season Big 10 postmortem?  This year college's most esteemed conference simultaneously broke the mold and lived up to its reputation.  How's that?

610x_medium

Will both Paterno and Tressel spread the conference wealth by bringing home BCS bacon?

It starts with the national pulse.  Coming into the season, we were the Water Buffaloes -- slow, brute, herbivores stuck in the mud; prone to dissection by smaller, faster foes.

Thirteen weeks of play later, our reputation proceeds us.  Sure, the Big 10 ranks third in 2008 out of conference win/loss records, finishing a hefty 31 and 9:

2008 Out of Conference Scorecard
1. SEC (28-5-0)--0.84848
2. Big 12 (38-10-0)--0.79167
3. Big Ten (31-9-0)--0.77500
4. ACC (28-10-0)--0.73684
5. MWC (23-11-0)--0.67647
6. Big East (21-12-0)--0.63636
7. Independent (11-11-0)--0.50000
8. WAC (16-17-0)--0.48485
9. Pac-10 (13-15-0)--0.46429
10. CUSA (16-23-0)--0.41026
11. MAC (17-27-0)--0.38636
12. Sun Belt (8-21-0)--0.27586
  (250-171-0)--0.59382

Source: Sportsline.com

But, the quality of the out of conference wins is subject to scrutiny.  When re-factored to consider our non-conference opponent's win/loss records, the Big 10 falls well into the bottom half of FBS contenders. 

1.    Pac-10    (82-38-0)--0.683
2.    ACC    (107-60-0)--0.641
3.    Big East    (88-56-0)--0.611
4.    CUSA    (96-64-0)--0.600
5.    Indep.         (55-41-0)--0.573
6.    MAC    (104-82-0)--0.559
7.    Sun Belt    (71-58-0)--0.550
8.    Big Ten    (93-76-0)--0.550
9.    Big 12    (109-91-0)--0.545
10.    WAC    (77-68-0)--0.531
11.    MWC    (74-68-0)--0.521
12.    SEC    (70-67-0)--0.511

And, numbers can only be used to say so much.  Humor me for a second and think of the best Big 10 out of conference win you can recall from this season....Got it?

If you said Penn State's 45-14 shellacking of suddenly-slipperless Oregon State, we're on the same wavelength.  Everything else that comes to mind on the national front -- Ohio State's humiliation in the Colosseum, Michigan State's debut drop at California, Michigan's foreshadowing fall against Utah -- is well, embarassing.

Granted, it could be much worse: we could be the Pac 10.  But, coupled with the North's struggles against our newest acronymic adversary -- the MAC -- it's hard to argue the Big 10 made any gains in reputation this regular season.  Especially, when you take into account my less than optimistic outlook on our upcoming bowl demise.

But why did this year feel so different?

It could have been the shakeup of the pecking order.  After, all big brutes like Michigan and Wisconsin fell far from grace -- tumbling from their routine perches near the top of the conference standings to damn near rock bottom.  Fresher faces, like Prodigal Son MSU, and brainy Northwestern swooped into to take their place.

Oh yeah, and Ohio State didn't win.  At least not outright.  In fact -- much to Graham's chagrin -- someone finally punched them in the mouth.  It just goes to show you why you don't cut in front of Joe Pa in the MCL Cafeteria line. 

539w_medium

Any given Saturday...

But ultimately, this year's "change" in pulse comes from a newly minted top to bottom competitiveness.  Or -- to borrow a page from our friends down South -- the birth of the "Any Given Saturday" mentality in the Big 10.

How many times this season did you find yourself 1. Actually watching 12:00 noon games, and 2. Actively scrolling between ESPN 2 and the Big Ten Network to keep up with the latest conference overachiever?

Don't buy it?  Check out any of the following: Michigan v. Wisconsin, Minnesota v. illinois, Northwestern v. Minnesota, Illinois v. Michigan, Iowa v. Penn State, Illinois v. Iowa, Indiana v. Northwestern, Purdue v. Michigan, Wisconsin v. Minnesota.

Considering the snake-like coil of the Race to the Top, it shouldn't be any surprise that the Big 10's pocketbook is the big winner in the wake of No. 23 Oregon's 65-38 drubbing of No. 17 Oregon State, as the conference now stands poised to put both Penn State and Ohio State in the BCS.

Now, if we could just bring home a little more than petty cash from bowl season.  How about a little confidence?

0 recs | Comment 3 comments | Digg!

Read Related

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

well said....

i’ve been saying it all year, but it bears repeating again, we (as a conference) may have done ourselves no favors when it comes to national perception, but at least the myth of SEC parity has been smashed ( i’ve been savoring LSU and GA’s recent defeats like a oenophile enjoys a 1792 Bordeaux). overall, i think our top-to-bottom conference strength (despite the Illini and Badgers implosion) has increased, though we will have to wait for the bowls and next season for this to be readily apparent nation-wide. I think Ohio State and Penn State are both pre-season Top Ten and legitimate national title contenders next year. now if only Madame deFarge was knitting the names of Sagarin, Billingsley etc. into her list of of ancien regime dinosaurs about to be fed to the hungry maw of Madame Guillotine

hopes Maybin wipes his ass with some TP

by conquering lion in the 215 on Nov 30, 2008 11:33 AM CST   0 recs

I Love Lucie...

And I agree with conquering lion. Minnesota, Northwestern, Illinois, Michigan State...in the last 10 years, these teams have been consistently mediocre or bipolar (Illinois). But now these teams have solid coaches who have earned the support of the fan base and installed offensive/defensive systems that seem to work. That’s good news.

by grahamfiller10 on Nov 30, 2008 1:44 PM CST to parent up   0 recs

Great write-up

However, there’s an almost perfect correlation between good OOC records and weak OOC opponents in your analysis. So while we have the Pac-10 facing the toughest opposition, and having the weakest OOC record, it’s difficult to tell whether that’s a function of the Pac-10’s inflating their opponents records by losing to them or the Pac-10 actually playing more difficult opponents. For example, Oregon State owns one of the OOC losses that mar the Pac-10, yet that loss was to a great opponent in PSU. On the other hand, UCLA has a loss to Tennessee, an embarrassment. Which is more indicative of a Pac-10 OOC loss? Or a Big 10 loss?

As far as the question of why the B10 seemed tougher this season despite seemingly little OOC to show for themselves? I imagine that it has something to do with the SEC looking so mediocre. So while the Big Ten had a few rather embarassing losses, they did not experience complete domination comparable to the unofficial ACC/SEC challenge, or any impressive victories comparable to PSU/OrSU. In other words, the Big Ten looks better not because of a perception of it’s impressiveness, but rather because the perceptions of the other conferences (barring the Big 12) have fallen back to Earth and reality in comparison.

by AgnosticTheocrat on Dec 1, 2008 8:49 PM CST   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools



The quintessential smoking room for all things Big 10 Football.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Little_girl_yelling_at_donkey_small
I'm a thief, but OK with it
Avatar_small
MSU and their rented coach??
Ww_small
Where has THAT offense been all year? (Old Oaken Bucket Game)
James4_small
2009 College Football recruiting rankings as of 11/13/09
James4_small
College Football/How accurate are Pre-Season rankings
James4_small
Where does MSU stack up in recruiting against other conf?
James4_small
Michigan State Overload: Spartan Recruiting at the Skill Positions, Past and Present
James4_small
Michigan State Overload: Linebacker recruiting past/present
James4_small
Michigan State recruiting past and future, statistics on DL
James4_small
Michigan State Overload: recruiting stats OL

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Managers

M_small grahamfiller10

Cigar_small Law Buckeye

Authors

Bama_hawkeye_small Bama Hawkeye

ad

Site Meter