The Rivalry, Esq.: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Around SBN: Race to the BCS: rankings, in-game scores & blogs Bar-right-arrows



spread the word

The Big Ten-SEC Challenge

Imagine if you will a world where athletic directors and conference comissioners are bold, fearless, and do what is best for their fans.  Imagine a world in which conferences will put their manhood on the line and face off to see which conference is the best.  That's right, what follows is a work of science fiction.

As we suffer through another Big Ten drubbing in the ACC-Big Ten Challenge (do we even win a game tonight?), imagine if ten years ago when that series was created the Big Ten entered into a similar series with the SEC - but in football.  Yes, because football schedules are made so far in advance the series wouldn't begin immediately, as the Big Ten's basketball series did.  Instead it would run for two years in 2009 and 2010.  

109_medium

 

Star-divide

The parameters were agreed to in an undiclosed location.  Based upon the conference standings of the 2008 season, the SEC and Big Ten would match up their teams.  The 7th Place SEC team would skip the challenge.  Teams would get a home game and a road game and not play the same team twice.  To make things more sporting, the SEC home games would be in the second weekend in September.  The Big Ten home games would be in the second weekend in November.

As fate wold have it, 3-5 LSU was left out of the challenge.  These eleven games were scheduled to take place.

 

Date Visitor Home
Nov. 14, 2009 Alabama Penn St.
Nov. 14, 2009 Florida Ohio St.
Sept. 12, 2009 Michigan St. Georgia
Sept. 12, 2009 Northwestern Mississippi
Sept. 12, 2009 Iowa Vanderbilt
Sept. 12, 2009 Wisconsin South Carolina
Nov. 14, 2009 Tennessee Minnesota
Nov. 14, 2009 Kentucky Illinois
Nov. 14, 2009 Auburn Michigan
Spet. 12, 2009 Purdue Arkansas
Sept. 12, 2009 Indiana Mississippi St.

 

I won't spoil the results of each game, but I will inform you that the SEC argued that they would have come away with the 6-5 series win "if the game in Minneapolis wasn't played in sub-human conditions."  It should be noted that LSU faced Arkansas State and Idaho State on these two weekends.

Tcfbankstadium_medium

Who knew that the outdoors would be the difference?

 

The matchups the next year proved just as intriguing.  

 

Date Visitor Home
Sept. 11, 2010 Ohio State Alabama
Sept. 11, 2010 Penn State Florida
Nov. 13, 2010 Georgia Northwestern
Nov. 13, 2010 Mississippi Michigan State
Nov. 13, 2010 Vanderbilt Wisconsin
Nov. 13, 2010 South Carolina Iowa
Sept. 11, 2010 Illinois Tennessee
Sept. 11, 2010 Michigan Kentucky
Sept. 11, 2010 Minnesota Auburn
Nov. 13, 2010 Arkansas Indiana
Nov. 13, 2010 Mississippi St. Purdue

 

The SEC won 6 of the 11 games during the second challenge.  Nowhere was the clash of cultures more pronounced than in Evanston, Illinois.  "How can you not fill a stadium this small?" was the common refrain from the Bulldog fans which outnumbered the purple faithful.

Openseatwt9_medium_medium

H/T to Hayden Fry's Moustache Ride

It was a good series that ended in a two year draw.  After it was done, the conferences walked away and went back to scheduling the Sun Belt and MAC teams that paid the bills.

Seriously though, how cool would it be to have something like this?  If you prefer, imagine the same idea with the Big XII (sans 7th Place Kansas)...

 

2009 Visitor 2009 Home 2010 Visitor 2010 Home
Penn State Oklahoma Texas Penn State
Ohio State Texas Oklahoma Ohio State
Texas Tech Michigan State Michigan State Oklahoma State
Oklahoma State Northwestern Northwestern Texas Tech
Missouri Iowa Iowa Nebraska
Nebraska Wisconsin Wisconsin Missouri
Minnesota Colorado Kansas State Minnesota
Illinois Kansas State Baylor Illinois
Michigan Baylor Colorado Michigan
Texas A&M Purdue Purdue Iowa State
Iowa State Indiana Indiana Texas A&M

It'd be a good deal for all involved.  It's a shame it will never happen.

0 recs | Comment 5 comments | Digg!

Read Related

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

As we suffer through another Big Ten drubbing in the ACC-Big Ten Challenge (do we even win a game tonight?),

I hope that was serious sarcasm.

by gahnki on Dec 3, 2008 2:25 PM CST   0 recs

Fantasy is a superlative...

It’s the ultimate ideal.

I’ve had almost as much fun reading your latest effort as I do actually watching our teams play unimaginative opponents (we’ll call them Arkansas State and Idaho State for no particular reason…)

My particular favorite is Florida’s hypothetical visit to the ‘Shoe in November. Imagine their reaction to the blistering gusts, heavy flakes, and lifeless gray sky. It’s a perfect pale-skinned hell.

And there aren’t sideline heaters…

We’re sending this article to the Network Big Wigs to have it featured on the main page. Hopefully that will generate a flurry of perspectives from all over SBN.

by Law Buckeye on Dec 3, 2008 3:58 PM CST   0 recs

Well...

Imagine how many Buckeye would be cramping up and heaving on the sidelines during a mid-afternoon game in Gainesville in September. It’s a hot, humid, soul-sapping hell.

I’ve been to both Columbus in winter and I spent 4 years at UF, and I can tell you they are pretty good analogues on opposite ends of the spectrum. And my fiancee (originally a Floridian like I am) who went to UF undergrad and is now at grad school at OSU assures me that summer in Ohio is nowhere near summer in Florida.

Anyway, this would be a fun construct to have. I doubt anything like this would happen between the Big Ten and any other BCS conference because Jim Delaney seems like he’d never do anything that could potentially compromise the Big Ten brand he’s trying to build. If his conference didn’t do so hot a couple years in a row, it wouldn’t look very good on the conference’s reputation, something he is tasked as commissioner to uphold.

Not that the SEC would automatically jump headlong into it either, but if you flash enough dollar signs, the folks down here will try just about anything once.

by Year2 on Dec 4, 2008 12:03 AM CST to parent up   0 recs

The Eternal Struggle...

On one hand, everyone loves easy non-conference wins that boost the win total…On the other hand, winning a tough early matchup pays dividends (big game experience, national recognition, stronger BCS rating)…

The logical next question is: What would pull these two conferences together besides money? Or is it only money?

by grahamfiller10 on Dec 4, 2008 8:21 AM CST to parent up   0 recs

It's always money.

Truth be told, a lot of the matchups wouldn’t be that novel. We’ve seen them in the Outback Bowl/Capital One Bowl/Music City Bowl in year’s past (especially when Tennessee and Michigan move back into their customary places in the pecking order. A series would likely work better with the Big 12 or even the ACC.

by Bama Hawkeye on Dec 4, 2008 8:40 AM CST to parent up   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools



The quintessential smoking room for all things Big 10 Football.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Little_girl_yelling_at_donkey_small
I'm a thief, but OK with it
Avatar_small
MSU and their rented coach??
Ww_small
Where has THAT offense been all year? (Old Oaken Bucket Game)
James4_small
2009 College Football recruiting rankings as of 11/13/09
James4_small
College Football/How accurate are Pre-Season rankings
James4_small
Where does MSU stack up in recruiting against other conf?
James4_small
Michigan State Overload: Spartan Recruiting at the Skill Positions, Past and Present
James4_small
Michigan State Overload: Linebacker recruiting past/present
James4_small
Michigan State recruiting past and future, statistics on DL
James4_small
Michigan State Overload: recruiting stats OL

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Managers

M_small grahamfiller10

Cigar_small Law Buckeye

Authors

Bama_hawkeye_small Bama Hawkeye

ad

Site Meter