The Rivalry, Esq.: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Around SBN: SEC Basketball at the Half

College Football: Is Michigan the New Notre Dame?

Bloated endowments, legendary stars, tradition oozing out every gold and maize orifice. The only thing lacking? Top notch college football teams.

As ESPN lauds the current Michigan recruiting class and many express surprise at the number of standout players that RichRod was able to grab after a 3-9 season, I couldn't help but make a comparison to the football program in South Bend. This scary parallel won't do much to assuage the fears of Wolverine fans, but some of the similarities ring too true to ignore.

Recruiting: Everyone knows that Notre Dame can recruit. In 2008, ND had the 2nd best recruiting class in the nation according to Rivals. 2006 and 2007? #8 in the nation both years. Every year, a top ranked high school player will surprise everyone and pick Notre Dame. Unfortunately, these recruits and the stars who preceeded them, have not been able to pull Notre Dame out of mediocrity. Through the last 10 years, the Irish have gone a dismal 69-53.

So as Michigan puts together the #7 recruiting class, complete with two high school quarterbacks who look 100 times superior to Michigan's 2008 QB's, let me give you a name to remember: Jimmy Clausen. This "once every 10 years" recruit has showed flashes of brilliance at ND, but has been brought back down to earth by the overwhelming mediocrity of the Irish.

Notre_dame_helmet_medium

Bring down the expectations from the sky...

Belief in Tradition Amongst Horrible Bowl Performances: It says volumes that Notre Dame was able to grab a fat TV contract amidst its worst 10 year run since the 1950s. The fan base and maybe some interested onlookers see the gold helmets and they believe they are watching top level FBS football. That's why the painting of the helmets continues, that's why the signature endzone remains, and that's why the NCAA put the CFB Hall of Fame in South Bend. But it's an illusion to think that ND is a national powerhouse - and everyone knows it. When the Irish get a chance to prove their grit against competition from the West or South, what happens? A 1-9 bowl record in it's last 10 postseason contests.

In Ann Arbor, much of the same mentality exists. It's Michigan dammit, we're entitled to a Top 10 team, we always line up future NFLers on both sides of the ball. But sometimes I wonder if that time has passed and those expectations should be tempered a bit. The MGoBlue banner hasn't been held up for a legitimate national contender in 11 years and even the 11-2 2006 team looked overmatched against the two Top 5 teams it faced at the end of the year. Losing four bowls in a row from 2004-2008 didn't help Michigan's national reputation either.

Overreaction and Summary: Maybe Michigan's transition to the Spread will yield numerous national titles and maybe the Irish will spring new life from their top ranked recruits. It won't be from lack of fan support, let me tell you that. There are more good Michigan football blogs on the Internet than any other single team and there are tons of wealthy, dedicated Irish fans willing to throw some cash toward beloved Touchdown Jesus and his mother Mary.

So I say: let these underperforming legends slum it with the rest of College Football's middle tier until they break into the Top 10 on merit alone. Then, cue the praise and fawning, because it's been awhile since it was rightly deserved.

0 recs  |  Comment 3 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

No

One transition year with an obvious lack of experience at many positions does not put U-M even close to the situation that ND is in. I understand that the comparison is easy to make because of the timing of each program hitting hard times, but if you looked at this situation on broader scale, then you would have never posted this article.

by wolvzilla on Feb 9, 2009 9:20 AM CST reply actions   0 recs

To answer the title question...

No. Michigan, despite post-season failings, has been much more solid since the early 90s than ND, who has not even been a national story for some time. Michigan has been having very good to great seasons for most of that stretch. They could conceivably become the next Notre Dame, but it will take about a decade of underperforming to get there.

But I think the overall problem with this piece is the final statement:

So I say: let these underperforming legends slum it with the rest of College Football’s middle tier until they break into the Top 10 on merit alone. Then, cue the praise and fawning, because it’s been awhile since it was rightly deserved.

So wait…what fawning has happened? Recruiting? It’s pretty undeniable that both schools have pulled in good to great recruiting classes. So, when that is accomplished, it will be talked about. But beyond that, what fawning has happened? There was no praise for either team this year, and none for ND last year, and little for Michigan. Hell, they didn’t even get national credit for their Bowl victory over Florida.

This seems to be more a rant against the fact that Michigan and Notre Dame will always get a lot of coverage. Yet this will always happen, because they simply have more fans than other schools. Michigan’s alumni base is absolutely massive, and that will drive coverage. Notre Dame has had a national following for decades, and it will take a loooong time for that to end.

--AddictedToQuack, SBNation's Oregon Ducks blog

by jtlight on Feb 9, 2009 10:06 AM CST reply actions   0 recs

Check My Icon

That’s a Michigan hat, I am Michigan fan. It’s not a Drew Sharp-esque one-sided rant…This was an attack on having a mentality of a Top 5 team, even though we haven’t been rated in the Top 5 at the end of a season since 1997. I had to ask the question because I saw similarities between the two most tradition laden programs in CFB. I guess the best way to rebut this article is to simply win more games…

by grahamfiller10 on Feb 9, 2009 10:37 AM CST up reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools


Overpowering Top 15 teams since 2010.
Start posting on The Rivalry, Esq. »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
NOTRE DAME & THE BIG TEN
Cigar_small
Under Armor All-America High School Football Game
Dodge_front_small
Gophers need to hire Mike Leach
Oscar-gamble-avatar_small
The Big Ten Expansion Index
Small
"THE HOLLAND PLAN" BIG-10 EXPANSION
Small
Big Ten Expansion? The Chadnudj Plan
Small
Florida receives tough to swallow BCS bowl
M_small
Is Nick Saban actually Agent Smith from The Matrix?
Small
Big Ten-ACC Rivalry Discussion Post
M_small
The Blind Side Movie Reviews Are In: Schmaltzy, Uplifting, Formulaic...Fresh?

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managers

M_small grahamfiller10

Cigar_small Law Buckeye

Bama_hawkeye_small Bama Hawkeye

Authors

Caddyshack12_small jerdogg1

Wrigley_small hmlee

N2200586_33075576_4358_small GregGoBlue

Official Partner of CBS Sports